Strangers with unknown histories
No one knows the other dogs' temperament, triggers, health, or history. Your dog is asked to get along with whoever shows up.
Dog parks
Period. The idea is a good one: dogs running, playing, and socializing together. The problem is the people. Too many owners don't watch their dogs, can't read the signals, and don't step in. That turns the dog park into the place where so much unbalanced behavior is practiced and made worse, a view shared by many experienced behavior professionals.
From the founder
I walked Nyx past a dog park. There were three dogs. One was territorial, claiming its space, and another was barking. Both triggered Nyx. I let her get close to the one that was barking, but the territorial dog came in, and she barked. Those two dogs came charging.
Their owners were just watching and talking.
The third dog, a Pit Bull, stayed with its people. It barked, but otherwise it stayed calm.
Inside the dog's mind
No one knows the other dogs' temperament, triggers, health, or history. Your dog is asked to get along with whoever shows up.
A crowd of excited dogs pushes many dogs over threshold. Each new arrival, chase, and bark adds to it, and a dog over threshold reacts instead of thinking.
Many owners talk, scroll, or relax while their dog runs the show. Rude, pushy, or bullying behavior goes uninterrupted, and other dogs pay for it.
Without structure, dogs rehearse rushing, mobbing, bullying, and ignoring their people. Whatever a dog practices, it gets better at.
Dogs crowd every newcomer at the entrance and patrol the fence line, treating the park as their space. A dog walking past can be read as an intruder.
Different sizes, ages, play styles, and energy levels are mixed together. A bigger dog's chase can switch from play to predatory behavior with a small dog.
Balls, toys, water bowls, benches, and even owners can be claimed, which creates conflict between dogs that don't know each other.
Many dogs become more selective about other dogs as they mature. A dog that tolerates the park is not the same as a dog that enjoys it.
By the numbers
of 300 dogs at three Northern California dog parks carried intestinal pathogens; more than half of those showed no diarrhea.
Hascall et al., 2016of 355 dogs sampled in nine Calgary parks carried intestinal parasites; about 1 in 4 had Giardia.
Smith et al., 2014Lisbon dog parks had hookworm eggs in the soil, and 33% of 369 fecal samples were infected.
Ferreira et al., 2017of UK owners said their dog currently shows aggression (barking, lunging, growling, or biting) toward unfamiliar dogs.
Casey et al., 2013The American Veterinary Medical Association also lists dogs that are regularly around other dogs, including at dog parks, daycare, boarding, and grooming, as at greater risk of canine influenza.
Evidence
The research on dog parks is limited and mixed, and we think you deserve both sides. Every study below is peer-reviewed and linked to its source.
Dogs' saliva cortisol, a hormone tied to arousal and stress, rose significantly after 20 minutes in a dog park, but did not rise in the same dogs after a 20-minute on-leash walk. Dogs that visited the park least often had the highest cortisol, and a hunched posture went with higher cortisol.
What it means: The dog park raises arousal in a way a walk with you does not.
Who was studied: Companion dogs observed at an off-leash park in Newfoundland, Canada.
Ottenheimer Carrier, L., Cyr, A., Anderson, R. E., & Walsh, C. J. (2013). Exploring the dog park: Relationships between social behaviours, personality and cortisol in companion dogs. Applied Animal Behaviour Science, 146(1–4), 96–106. Read the study
Dogs played with each other significantly more when their owner was present and paying attention than when the owner was present but not paying attention, or absent.
What it means: Dogs notice whether their owner is engaged. An owner on the phone is, to the dog, an owner who isn't there.
Who was studied: Ten pairs of familiar dogs, each tested in three conditions over repeated sessions.
Mehrkam, L. R., & Wynne, C. D. L. (2021). Owner attention facilitates social play in dog–dog dyads. Animal Cognition, 24, 341–352. Read the study
Intestinal pathogens were found in 114 of 300 dogs (38%), and 62 of those (54%) had no diarrhea. Nine percent carried Giardia. Dogs that went to the park more often had looser stool, though visit frequency was not linked to whether a pathogen was found.
What it means: Dogs that look healthy can still be shedding parasites at the park.
Who was studied: 300 dogs at three regional dog parks in Northern California.
Hascall, K. L., Kass, P. H., Saksen, J., et al. (2016). Prevalence of enteropathogens in dogs attending 3 regional dog parks in Northern California. Journal of Veterinary Internal Medicine, 30(6), 1838–1845. Read the study
Half of the dogs (50.2%) carried intestinal parasites: Giardia (24.7%), Cystoisospora (16.8%), and Cryptosporidium (14.7%). Infection was more likely in dogs that visited multiple parks, visited often, and spent time off leash.
What it means: More park time and more off-leash time meant more exposure.
Who was studied: 645 owner questionnaires and fecal samples from 355 dogs in nine Calgary city parks.
Smith, A. F., Semeniuk, C. A., Kutz, S. J., & Massolo, A. (2014). Dog-walking behaviours affect gastrointestinal parasitism in park-attending dogs. Parasites & Vectors, 7, 429. Read the study
33% of fecal samples carried at least one parasite, including hookworm (16.5%), Cryptosporidium (11.9%), and Giardia (11.4%). The soil in all three parks was contaminated with hookworm eggs.
What it means: The ground itself can carry parasites, even when no sick dog is in sight.
Who was studied: 369 fecal samples, 18 soil samples, and 102 owner interviews at three dog parks in Lisbon, Portugal.
Ferreira, A., Alho, A. M., Otero, D., et al. (2017). Urban dog parks as sources of canine parasites. Journal of Environmental and Public Health, 2017, 5984086. Read the study
22% of owners reported their dog currently shows aggression toward unfamiliar dogs (barking, lunging, growling, or biting).
What it means: In a park full of unfamiliar dogs, the odds that at least one of them doesn't welcome your dog are high.
Who was studied: Survey of UK dog owners.
Casey, R. A., Loftus, B., Bolster, C., Richards, G. J., & Blackwell, E. J. (2013). Inter-dog aggression in a UK owner survey. Veterinary Record, 172(5), 127. Read the study
Over 72 hours of observation, researchers recorded 14 clear aggressive episodes and 14 ambiguous ones, each lasting under a minute. Nine of 177 dogs (5%) were aggressive toward another dog, and no incident caused serious injury.
Our take: The authors credited owners who were "self-selecting, self-monitoring, and self-limiting." In other words, the park worked when owners were watching, which is exactly what we often don't see.
Who was studied: 177 dogs at one dog park, observed over 8 months.
Shyan, M. R., Fortune, K. A., & King, C. (2003). "Bark parks": A study on interdog aggression in a limited-control environment. Journal of Applied Animal Welfare Science, 6(1), 25–32. Read the study
In the first 400 seconds after entering, sniffing and greeting were nearly universal and aggressive behaviors were rare. Much of the early contact was other dogs greeting the newcomer.
Our take: Short observations capture arrivals, not what builds over a long visit. Note how much attention every newcomer gets at the gate.
Who was studied: 69 dogs at a public off-leash park in Newfoundland, Canada.
Howse, M. S., Anderson, R. E., & Walsh, C. J. (2018). Social behaviour of domestic dogs in a public off-leash dog park. Behavioural Processes, 157, 691–701. Read the study
A 2018 public health review found that evidence on dog bites in off-leash parks is limited, and that the risk of parasites passing to people is relatively unknown (Rahim et al., 2018, Journal of Community Health, 43, 433–440, read the review). Most studies cover a single park, a short window of time, or a few hundred dogs. We share that so you can judge the evidence for yourself.
Serious fights at dog parks may be uncommon. But our concern was never just fights. The evidence shows that dog parks raise arousal, that dogs notice whether their owners are paying attention, that unfamiliar dogs often don't welcome each other, and that parasites are common in park dogs and park soil. Put that together with owners who aren't watching, and a dog can come home without a scratch and still be learning the wrong lessons, one visit at a time. That's why we don't recommend dog parks at all.
Better options
Your dog doesn't need a crowd of strangers to be social and fulfilled. It needs exercise, structure, and the right kind of company.
Exercise, mental work, and connection with you, without the chaos.
Play dates with well-matched dogs whose owners you know and trust.
Dogs walking together with handlers who are engaged and in control.
A long line in a quiet, safe area so your dog can explore at its own pace.
Agility, nose work, dock diving, and more give drive and energy a real job.
Learn the warning signs on our Body Language page, and why arousal matters on Impulse Control.
We'll help you understand what your dog needs and build a routine that leaves it calm and fulfilled.
Start a conversation